
One of the most famous lines of American poetry
Over my head, I see the bronze butterfly
Asleep on the black trunk,
Blowing like a leaf in green shadow.
Down the ravine behind the empty house,
The cowbells follow one another
Into the distances of the afternoon.
To my right,
In a field of sunlight between two pines,
The droppings of last year's horses
Blaze up into golden stones.
I lean back, as the evening darkens and comes on.
A chicken hawk floats over, looking for home.
I have wasted my life.
-- James Wright
It's so simple and heartfelt and ambiguous and unexpected. To me it has the same shocking and memorable conclusion as Rilke's Sonnet on an Archaic Torso of Apollo, which ends with the conclusion
"You must change your life".
You must, and still you might have wasted it. Who knows? And is that bad? Who knows even less? But it's soreal poetry to me, because it catches the contradictions and emotions of living, breathing, thinking, and those magical moments when - for better or worse - you see the world in a different way.
Back in 1964, the poet and critic Thom Gunn criticised those who went on about the newness of the poem, complained
The final line is perhaps exciting because we are surprised to encounter something so different from the rest of the poem, but it is certainly meaningless. The more one searches for an explicit meaning in it, the vaguer it becomes. Other general statements of different import could well be substituted for it and the poem would neither gain nor lose strength.
But another contemporary poet, Robert Bly, writing under the pseudonym of Clunk, argued back
It is clear Gunn does not understand the poem, or rather, it is not the poem he doesn’t understand but the emotion. He can’t bring himself to understand how an intelligent man would have such an emotion. After all, too, Gunn is an educated man; he has trained his intelligence; other people, chaotic ones, may have wasted their lives, but not he. What prevents Gunn from understanding is his habit of discursive reasoning, his rationalism. … In poems the deepest thoughts are often the most painful thoughts, and they come to consciousness only despite the rationalist road-blocks, by slipping past the defenses of the ego. In most men, the inner thoughts are never able to slip by these defenses of the ego. The ordinary mind has pickets everywhere, who make an impregnable ring.
I really sympathise with Bly on this - that's the emotion 'I have Wasted My Life" elicits in me. That unguarded spontaneous thought that lands in your lap like a hailstone on a clear day. However, Wright himself had his own explanation for the last line.
I think that I didn’t realize it at the moment, but looking back on that poem I think that final line – "I have wasted my life" – is a religious statement, that is to say, here I am and I’m not straining myself and yet I’m happy at this moment, and perhaps I’ve been wastefully unhappy in the past because through my arrogance or whatever, and in my blindness, I haven’t allowed myself to pay true attention to what was around me.
So who's right? And actually, in this instance, who's wright? We all invent that poem as we read it, and bring our own meaning to the end. That meaning will still surprise and shock us, precisely because it is forceful and simple yet completely ambiguous. The line is not striving to be wilfully obscure. Quire the opposite. It is striving to be emotionally honest and clear, and yet leaving us guessing. That's why this is SOREAL POETRY. Wright himself confesses as much in another interview
It is not surrealistic. I said, at the end of that poem, "I have wasted my life" because it was what I happened to feel at that moment and as part of the mood I had while lying in the hammock. This poem made English critics angry. I have never understood what would have so infuriated them. They could say the poem was limp or that it did not have enough intellectual content. I can see that. But I hope that it did not pretend to. It just said, I am lying here in this hammock and this and that is happening.
More on James Wright and his unusual background....
BIOGRAPHY of James Wright
James Arlington Wright was born in Martins Ferry, Ohio, on December 13,
1927. His father worked for fifty years at a glass factory, and his mother
left school at fourteen to work in a laundry; neither attended school
beyond the eighth grade. While in high school in 1943 Wright suffered a
nervous breakdown and missed a year of school. When he graduated in 1946,
a year late, he joined the army and was stationed in Japan during the
American occupation. He then attended Kenyon College on the G.I. Bill, and
studied under John Crowe Ransom. He graduated cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa
in 1952, then married another Martins Ferry native, Liberty Kardules. The
two traveled to Austria, where, on a Fulbright Fellowship, Wright studied
the works of Theodor Storm and Georg Trakl at the University of Vienna. He
returned to the U.S. and earned master's and doctoral degrees at the
University of Washington, studying with Theodore Roethke and Stanley
Kunitz. He went on to teach at The University of Minnesota, Macalester
College, and New York City's Hunter College.
The poverty and human suffering Wright witnessed as a child profoundly
influenced his writing and he used his poetry as a mode to discuss his
political and social concerns. He modeled his work after Thomas Hardy and
Robert Frost, whose engagement with profound human issues and emotions he
admired. The subjects of Wright's earlier books, The Green Wall (winner of
the Yale Series of Younger Poets award, 1957) and Saint Judas (1959),
include men and women who have lost love or have been marginalized from
society for such reasons as poverty and sexual orientation, and they
invite the reader to step in and experience the pain of their isolation.
Wright possessed the ability to reinvent his writing style at will, moving
easily from stage to stage. His earlier work adheres to conventional
systems of meter and stanza, while his later work exhibits more open,
looser forms, as with The Branch Will Not Break (1963). James Wright was
elected a fellow of The Academy of American Poets in 1971, and the
following year his Collected Poems received the Pulitzer Prize in poetry.
He died in New York City in 1980.
-- http://www.poets.org/poets/poets.cfm?prmID=74
Sorealism by Peter Jukes and Marcos D'Cruze is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial-Share Alike 2.0 UK: England & Wales License.
Comments
Generic Viagra | Cheap
Sat, 01/30/2010 - 10:06 — jamessmith12Generic Viagra | Cheap Generic Viagra | Generic Levitra | Generic Viagra | Cheap Generic Viagra | Kamagra | Cheap Generic Viagra | Finpecia | Penegra | Generic Viagra and Kamagra | Generic Viagra
We have huge quantity of
Mon, 02/01/2010 - 04:36 — uheyWe have huge quantity of Gucci Purses, Gucci Belts, Gucci Loafers and Gucci Sneakers for sale! You can find the exact gucci whether Gucci Men's Shoes or Gucci Women's Shoes you want at a price that's right for you.Moreover,we have the best quality Louis Vuitton Shoes on sale including Men's Shoes, We are professional brand shoes, Gucci Handbags, Gucci Shoes and satisfied customers always come first. We have huge quantity of Gucci Purses, Gucci Belts, Gucci Loafers and Gucci Sneakers for sale! You can find the exact gucci whether Gucci Men's Shoes or Gucci Women's Shoes you want at a price that's right for you.Moreover,We provide the best service and fast shipping to customers all over the world. High distinctive and exquisite quality Gucci Products like Gucci Handbags, Gucci Shoes and satisfied customers always come first. We have huge quantity of Gucci Purses, Gucci Belts, Gucci Loafers and Gucci Sneakers for sale! You can find the exact gucci whether Gucci Men's Shoes or Gucci Women's Shoes you want at a price that's right for you.Moreover,We are professional brand shoes.
Members that think I Have
Sun, 02/07/2010 - 23:53 — norbertherreraSecurity CCTV Camera | SEO
Tue, 02/16/2010 - 05:42 — james123Security CCTV Camera | SEO Service India| SEO Friendly Directory | Leather Bags | Navi Mumbai Real Estate